Wikivoyage

< Wikivoyage:Баннеры ВЛП 2018

Page banner competition was part of Wiki Loves Monuments 2018:

Results

править

Each jury member voted for 30 banners. Final score depends on the number of jury votes and banner usage:

  • 5 points for banners used in Wikivoyage travel guides
  • 3 points for banners used in meta-pages
  • 1 point for unused banners

For example, a banner voted by 3 jury members and used in a Wikivoyage travel guide (at least in one language version of Wikivoyage) scored 15 points.

Final grades:

(other participants scored less than 20 points)

Winners: A.Savin (Russian destinations) and Tsy1980 (international destinations). Congratulations!

Best banners

править
Valday, Russia
(8 out of 8 jury votes)
by A.Savin
Kimzha, Arkhangelsk Oblast, Russia
(7 out of 8 jury votes)
by Фото Алексей Романов
Kem, Karelia, Russia
(7 out of 8 jury votes)
by Kate Mikheeva
Beijing, China
(6 out of 8 jury votes)
by Tsy1980

Statistics

править
  • Number of banners: 461 (356 eligible)
  • Number of countries: 24
  • Best coverage: Russia (174 banners), Ukraine (131 banners)

Eligible banners

править
by Romain.pontida/ (4205x599)
by Romain.pontida/ (6797x971)


by Vintagejhan/ (3871x553)
by Vintagejhan/ (3871x553)
by Vintagejhan/ (6000x857)


by Ludvig14/ (10500x1500)
used in Минск
by Ludvig14/ (9450x1350)
by Ludvig14/ (14000x2000)


see en:Talk:Bremerhaven#Banner image

by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
used in en:Bremerhaven
by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)


see Talk:Barcelona, en:Talk:Barcelona/Ciutat Vella

by MHlopov/ (3888x555)
used in Барселона/Старый город
by MHlopov/ (2455x351)
used in en:Barcelona
by MHlopov/ (3886x555)
used in Барселона/Эшампле
by MHlopov/ (3888x555)
by MHlopov/ (4032x576)
by MHlopov/ (16382x2340)
by Poco a poco/ (9877x1411)


see en:Talk:Milan/Centro Storico

by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
used in en:Milan/Centro_Storico
by Tsy1980/ (4200x600)
used in Турин


Храм Неба

в Пекине, /Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
used in Север Китая]]


by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
by Екатерина Борисова/ (2221x318)


by Tsy1980/, (3500x500)
by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)


by Poco a poco/ (8526x1218)
by Poco a poco/ (10701x1529)


see en:Talk:Portugal

by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)


by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x1000)
used in Культурное наследие России/Архангельская область/Мезенский район
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x996)
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x1004)
used in Wikivoyage:Вики любит памятники 2018/Шорт-лист (под угрозой), Пинежье и Мезень
by Фото Алексей Романов/, (7000x996)
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x993)
used in Культурное_наследие_России/Архангельская_область/Онежский_район
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x1019)
by Фото Алексей Романов/, (7000x995)
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x1006)
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x1015)
used in Культурное наследие России/Архангельская область/Пинежский район
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x1001)
used in Культурное наследие России/Архангельская область/Плесецкий район
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x1021)
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x992)
used in Культурное наследие России/Архангельская область/Приморский район
by Digr/ (4032x576)
by Digr/, (4011x573)
used in Сольвычегодск
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x1018)
by Kate Mikheeva/ (2408x344)
by X217/, (6033x862)
used in Культурное наследие России/Архангельская область/Соловецкий район


by Anisantha/ (4606x658)


by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3965x566)
used in Культурное наследие России/Ярославская область/Ростов (часть 1)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3922x560)
used in Культурное наследие России/Ярославская область/Тутаев (часть 2)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (4000x571)
used in Культурное наследие России/Ярославская область/Тутаев (часть 1)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3745x535)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3738x534)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3980x568)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (4473x639)
used in Культурное наследие России/Ярославская область/Ярославль (часть 3)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3980x568)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3950x565)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3528x503)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (4034x576)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3852x542)
used in Культурное_наследие_России/Ярославская_область/Ярославль_(часть_1)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (4332x618)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (4332x618)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3653x522)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3702x525)
used in Культурное наследие России/Ярославская область/Ярославль
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3420x488)


by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3928x561)
by Никонико962/ (3836x548)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (4214x602)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3690x524)
by Никонико962/ (3934x562)
by Aleksandra057/ (8268x1181)
87 — Дом культуры железнодорожников /Jurfeld/ (5250 × 750)
by Jurfeld/ (3500x500)
used in Культурное наследие России/Москва/Центральный округ/За Садовым кольцом от просп. Мира до Стар. Басманной и Спартаковской ул.
by A.Savin/ (4025x575)
used in Москва/Лефортово
by A.Savin/ (3773x539)
used in Культурное наследие России/Москва/Центральный округ/Садовое кольцо
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3493x499)
used in Культурное_наследие_России/Москва/Центральный_округ/Полукольцо_центральных_площадей
by A.Savin/, (3262x466)
used in Москва/Поклонная гора и Дорогомилово
by A.Savin/ (2261x323)
used in Культурное наследие России/Москва/Центральный округ/От Пречистенской наб. до Воздвиженки
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3950x564)
by Rost.galis/ (2967x424)
by Rost.galis/ (2816x402)
used in Культурное наследие России/Москва/Восточный округ
Кусково

/Rost.galis/ (2742x392)]]

by Ludvig14/ (9100x1300)
used in Wikivoyage:Вики любит памятники 2018/Шорт-лист


by A.Savin/ (3185x455)
used in Культурное наследие России/Санкт-Петербург/Адмиралтейский район (часть 2)
by MHlopov/ (4026x572)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3843x549)
by Екатерина Борисова/ (2546x365)
by Екатерина Борисова/ (3050x437)
used in Культурное наследие России/Санкт-Петербург/Петроградский район (часть 1)
by Екатерина Борисова/ (3062x437)
used in Wikivoyage:Вики любит памятники 2018/Лонг-лист (часть 5)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3799x542)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3425x489)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3425x489)
used in Wikivoyage:Вики любит памятники 2018/Шорт-лист (детали)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3425x489)
by Екатерина Борисова/ (3058x437)
used in Культурное наследие России/Санкт-Петербург/Адмиралтейский район (часть 3)
by MHlopov/ (5764x822)
by Екатерина Борисова/ (3069x440)
by Екатерина Борисова/ (2952x422)
used in Культурное наследие России/Санкт-Петербург/Василеостровский район (Смоленское кладбище)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3878x552)
by MHlopov/ (9876x1411)
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3626x518)
by Jurfeld/ (3150x450)
by Jurfeld/ (4200x600)
by Jurfeld/ (4200x600)
used in Wikivoyage:Вики любит памятники 2018/Шорт-лист (интерьеры)
by AlixSaz/ (3500x500)
by MHlopov/ (5310x755)
used in Природные памятники России/Санкт-Петербург
by Николай Васильевич Белавин/ (3901x557)
by Zmitrun/ (4508x644)
by Екатерина Борисова/ (3066x437)
used in Культурное наследие России/Санкт-Петербург/Пушкин (часть 3)
by MHlopov/ (14468x2067)


Crimea (4)

править
by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
used in Ливадия, Культурное наследие/Крым/Ливадия
by V chekhov/ (2240x320)
by Zysko serhii/ (4047x578)
used in Судак
by V chekhov/ (2960x422)


by Romain.pontida/ (16671x2381)


by Vintagejhan/ (10612x1516)
by Yuriy kosygin/ (3500x500)
by Yuriy kosygin/ (3500x500)
by Yuriy kosygin/ (3500x500)


see Talk:Istanbul, en:Talk:Istanbul/Asian Side

191 — Мармарис /MHlopov/ (16354×2335)
by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
used in en:Istanbul/Asian Side
by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)


by Качуровська/ (4608x658)
used in uk:Бар
by V1snyk/ (5152x736)
by Posterrr/ (3500x500)
by V1snyk/ (4655x665)
by V1snyk/ (3115x445)
by V1snyk/ (4879x697)
by Качуровська/ (4593x657)
used in uk:Жмеринка
by Posterrr/ (3500x500)
by Качуровська/ (4608x657)
used in uk:Муровані Курилівці
by V1snyk/ (3024x432)
by Posterrr/ (3500x500)
used in uk:Тульчин
by Качуровська/ (4495x641)
used in uk:Хмільник
by V1snyk/ (4606x658)
used in uk:Шаргород


by Galvm/ (4255x607)
used in uk:Володимир-Волинський
by Galvm/ (4356x622)
by Galvm/ (3946x570)
by V1snyk/ (4893x699)
by Galvm/ (4000x571)
by Galvm/ (4000x571)
by Galvm/ (4000x571)
by Galvm/ (4510x644)


by V1snyk/ (5152x736)


by V chekhov/ (2240x320)
by V chekhov/, (5200x743, 7.0:1, 3.86 Mpx)


by V chekhov/ (2208x315)
by Сарапулов/ (10621x1517)
by Сарапулов/ (10135x1448)
by R naumov/ (2500x357)
by Сарапулов/ (17287x2470)
by Сарапулов/ (21511x3073)
by Сарапулов/ (12859x1837)
by Качуровська/ (4608x657)


by R naumov/ (2000x285)
by R naumov/ (2500x357)
by Сарапулов/ (10568x1510)
by Сарапулов/ (14694x2099)
by Сарапулов/ (18400x2628)
by Сарапулов/ (5048x722)
by Сарапулов/ (8189x1170)
by Сарапулов/ (19034x2719)
by Сарапулов/ (6000x858)
by Сарапулов/ (15212x2173)


by V1snyk/, (3003x429)
by Сарапулов/ (6000x858)
by V chekhov/ (2576x368)
by Zysko serhii/ (8827x1261)
by V chekhov/ (2224x318)
by V chekhov/ (2208x315)
by V chekhov/ (2272x325)
by Сарапулов/ (18568x2652)
by Сарапулов/ (11150x1593)
by Alina Vozna/ (3500x500)
by Zysko serhii/ (7436x1062)
used in Золотая подкова
by V1snyk/ (2975x425)
by V1snyk/ (3423x489)
by V1snyk/ (3402x486)


См. Обсуждение:Килия

by SalloAlex/ (1929x276)
used in Килия
by Качуровська/ (4160x594)
by Качуровська/ (4608x658)


by Качуровська/ (4368x625)
used in uk:Миргород
by Сарапулов/ (13596x1942)
by Сарапулов/ (5989x856)
by Сарапулов/ (11044x1578)
by Сарапулов/ (23168x3309)
by R naumov/ (2500x357)
used in Полтава
by Сарапулов/ (6000x857)
by Сарапулов/ (22404x3201)


by Antonello-kyiv/ (7782x1114)
used in uk:Дубно
by Galvm/, (3998x571)


by Lizabenet777/ (4032x576)
by Lizabenet777/ (15045x2141)
by Качуровська/ (4608x657)
by Lizabenet777/ (16382x2340)
by Lizabenet777/ (4086x584)
by Lizabenet777/ (8191x1165)
by Lizabenet777/ (4078x586)


by V1snyk/ (3101x443)
by V1snyk/ (5152x736)
by V1snyk/ (5152x736)
by V1snyk/ (5152x736)
by V1snyk/ (5152x736)
by V1snyk/ (3115x445)
by V1snyk/ (4830x690)
by V1snyk/ (5152x736)
by V1snyk/ (5152x736)
by V1snyk/ (2989x427)
by Posterrr/ (3500x500)
by Zysko serhii/ (5787x827)


by V chekhov/ (2176x311)


by Demin Vadim/ (3344x478)
by Demin Vadim/ (3356x479)
by Demin Vadim/ (5490x784)
by Demin Vadim/ (4149x593)
by Demin Vadim/ (4239x606)
by Demin Vadim/ (3341x477)
by Demin Vadim/ (1851x265)
by Demin Vadim/ (3184x455)


by V1snyk/ (4347x621)
by Zysko serhii/ (4602x657)
used in Меджибож
by Zysko serhii/ (5209x744)
by Djr2010/ (4200x600)
by Zysko serhii/ (6554x922)
by Zysko serhii/ (5315x759)
by Качуровська/ (4608x658)
by Alina Vozna/ (3500x500)
by V1snyk/ (3360x480)
by V1snyk/ (3052x436)
by V1snyk/ (3325x475)
by R naumov/ (2500x357)
by Alina Vozna/ (3500x500)
by Alina Vozna/ (3500x500)
by Alina Vozna/ (3500x500)
by Alina Vozna/ (3500x500)
by Alina Vozna/ (3500x500)
by Alina Vozna/, (3500x500, 7.0:1, 1.75 Mpx)
by Alina Vozna/ (3500x500)
by V1snyk/ (3178x454)


by Star61/ (15237x2177)
by Star61/ (21483x3069)
by Star61/ (24375x3482)
by V1snyk/ (5152x736)
by Качуровська/ (4608x658)
by Star61/ (22105x3158)


by V1snyk/ (4970x710)
by Sergiy Kovalenko KP/ (3990x570)
used in Хотин
by V1snyk/ (3402x486)
by V1snyk/ (5152x736)
by V1snyk/ (4893x699)


by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)


see en:Talk:Lourdes

by Moahim/ (14000x2000)
used in en:Lourdes


by Vintagejhan/ (3871x553)


by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)


by MHlopov/ (7696x1099)


see en:Talk:Cape Peninsula

by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
used in Кейптаун


by Vintagejhan/ (5536x790)


Ineligible banners

править

Wrong aspect ratio (52)

править

More banners with the wrong aspect ratio on Commons

by Rost.galis/ (1953x299, 6.5:1)
by Rasim1992/ (2342x431, 5.4:1)
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x1023, 6.8:1)
used in Wikivoyage:Вики любит памятники 2018/Лонг-лист (часть 1) - как Видягино Архангельская обл. (cropped).jpg
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x1033, 6.8:1)
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x1028, 6.8:1)
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x1026, 6.8:1)
by Александра Михалева/ (13868x2928, 4.7:1)
by Tatiana Kuzniecowa Wiensko/ (5777x983, 5.9:1)
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x1046, 6.7:1)
used in Лальск - как Лальск баннер (cropped).jpg
by Aleksandra057/ (11809x1969, 6.0:1)
by Vintagejhan/ (12416x1856, 6.7:1)
by Alina Vozna/ (3500x700, 5.0:1)


Low quality (8)

править
by V chekhov/ (2880x411)
by V chekhov/ (1776x254)
by V1snyk/ (4606x658)
by Demin Vadim/ (4240x606)
by Demin Vadim/ (6979x997)
by Lizabenet777/ (12238x1749)
by Lizabenet777/ (3728x544)


Out of scope (43)

править

Banners not representing the cultural heritage

by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
by Romain.pontida/ (9225x1317)
used in en:Doha
by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
by Nartin r/ (2600x371)
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (4724x675)
by Фото Алексей Романов/ (7000x1018)
by Rost.galis/ (3810x544)
used in Неман
by Rost.galis/ (6048x864)
used in Пионерский
by Rost.galis/ (3200x458)
used in Янтарный
by Rost.galis/ (4601x657)
by Ёгамрит/ (4442x635)
by Ёгамрит/ (8274x1182)
used in Маркс
by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
by Rost.galis/ (2801x400)
by Rost.galis/ (4000x571)
used in Москва/Восток
by Aleksandra057/ (12402x1772)
by Aleksandra057/ (4629x661)
by Rost.galis/ (3373x482)
by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
used in Партенит
by V chekhov/ (4912x702)
by V chekhov/ (4848x693)
by Digr/ (3997x571)
used in Ханты-Мансийск
by Digr/ (4032x576)
by Galvm/ (4000x571)
by Galvm/ (4000x571)
by Сарапулов/ (6000x857)
by Сарапулов/ (27618x3946)
by Сарапулов/ (28714x4102)
by Сарапулов/ (6000x857)
by Сарапулов/ (12164x1738)
by Сарапулов/ (6000x857)
by Сарапулов/ (10069x1438)
by Test-off/ (4200x601)
by Сарапулов/ (12121x1732)
by Lizabenet777/ (12100x1727)
by Lizabenet777/ (2144x307)
by Lizabenet777/, (4576x654)
by Demin Vadim/ (4459x637)
by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
used in en:Los Andes
by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)
by Tsy1980/ (3500x500)


Miscallaneous

править

Collages are not allowed by the Wikivoyage policy

by Rost.galis/ (18942x2706)
by Rost.galis/ (13104x1872)


Источник — https://ru.wikivoyage.org/w/index.php?title=Wikivoyage:Баннеры_ВЛП_2018/en&oldid=695387